Using the narrative inquiry research method, this self-study of the author’s teacher education practices examines the influence of four simultaneous accountability reviews on her personal experiences and identity within academia. Drawing on evidence excerpted from journal entries, work samples, historical documents and meeting notes, the author reconstructs a series of changes concerning human subjects reviews, course syllabi requirements, student assignments, grading procedures and personal productivity. The self inquiry reveals individual and institutional compromises that were made to achieve acceptable measures of success as determined by external agencies.