The researchers were interested in a prospective science teacher’s reflections on the feedback she received from the course instructors. Furthermore, the researchers were interested to examine how her struggle to make sense of an online content literacy course caused the researchers to reflect on several contradictory discourses in the online course that needed addressing before offering it in subsequent semesters. Implications derived from the study’s findings for literacy educators point to the value of collaborating with colleagues in schools of teacher education who have expertise in teaching their specific discipline’s content.