This study aimed to examine what prospective teachers (PSTs) noticed while watching video of their own co-teaching, particularly in a microteaching setting that consisted of peers. The findings reveal that PSTs PSTs demonstrated the ability to look beyond themselves in the video and focus on students and student learning. The majority of PSTs' observations also included some aspect of the mathematical content they were attempting to help students understand in the video. PSTs also demonstrated the ability to dissect specific moments of their teaching. They also consider some observations in regard to previous teaching experiences and theories.